Skip to main content
Start free
Start free

How can a landlord spot a fake ID or a made-up rental applicant?

DoorKeeping team

3 min read

Verify identity the same way for every applicant: compare the photo ID to the person in front of you or on a live video call, run the screening report with the name and number the applicant gave, and confirm that the details on the ID, the application and the screening report all agree. A mismatch is a reason to pause and ask, not to accuse. Apply the same steps to everyone, because uneven checks can create fair housing problems.

Three kinds of identity problems

Not every identity problem is the same, and the response is different for each.

  • A forged or altered ID: a real person's details with a changed photo, or a made-up card.
  • A stolen identity: a real person's name and number used by someone else, who then lives in the unit while the real person never knows.
  • An invented person: a name and number that do not belong to anyone, sometimes built to look like a credit file over time.

The FTC's IdentityTheft.gov explains how stolen personal information is used to open accounts and take other actions in the victim's name. A rental can be one more way it is used.

Checks that catch most problems

  1. Meet the applicant, in person or on live video, and compare the photo ID to the face. Text photos of an ID are easy to fake.
  2. Ask for the same ID type from every adult applicant, and write that rule down.
  3. Look at the ID itself: the name matches the application, the birth date matches, the card is not expired and the photo looks like an original, not a paste-on.
  4. Run the screening report with the name, date of birth and number from the application, and check that the report returns a file with a history that fits the stated age.
  5. Compare the address history on the report with the application, and call prior landlords at numbers you find yourself.
  6. Check that the phone number and email are not brand new and not tied to an unrelated name.
  7. Confirm income documents against the employer through a number you look up, not the one on the page.

A thin or brand-new credit file is not proof of fraud. Young adults and recent arrivals have little history. Treat it as a reason to ask for more documents, in line with your written criteria.

Red flags worth a second look

  • The applicant refuses any live contact and insists on email only.
  • The ID photo is blurry or cropped to hide an edge.
  • The name on the ID differs from the name on the application with no explanation.
  • The screening report shows a different date of birth, address or number than the application.
  • A rush to move in with cash or an unusual payment method.
  • Reference phone numbers that lead only back to the applicant.

When one of these appears, ask a neutral question and give the person a chance to explain. A typo in a birth date is common. An ID that cannot be explained is something else.

Stay fair and protect what you collect

Fair housing law bars treating applicants differently because of a protected class, such as race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status or disability. Federal law is at 42 U.S.C. 3604, and many states and cities add more. Asking only some applicants for extra proof, such as those with a foreign accent or name, can look like discrimination. The simplest protection is a written checklist that you apply to everyone.

Once you have collected IDs, protect them. A scan of a driver's license is among the most useful things a thief can take, so store it encrypted behind a login, limit who can see it and delete it on a schedule.

If an applicant turns out to have used someone else's identity, do not confront them. Decline the application using your normal process, keep your records and consider reporting to local police and the FTC.

Sources

  1. FTC, IdentityTheft.gov, read Oct 30, 2026
  2. 42 U.S.C. 3604, Discrimination in the sale or rental of housing, read Oct 30, 2026
  3. FTC, Protecting Personal Information: A Guide for Business, read Oct 30, 2026

Questions

Is it legal to require a photo ID from rental applicants?
Generally yes, if you require it from every adult applicant in the same way. Check your state's and city's rules on what you may request.
Does a thin credit file mean the applicant is fake?
No. Young adults and people new to the country often have little history. Ask for more documents under your written criteria instead of assuming fraud.
What should I do if I think an applicant used a stolen identity?
Do not accuse them. Decline through your normal process, keep your records and consider reporting to local police and the FTC.

Keep reading